Delaware Statutory Trust vs Deferred Sales Trust

Two tools, one confusing short name

In real estate, the same three letters get used for two unrelated things, which is why this site always spells them out. A Delaware statutory trust is an ownership vehicle for real estate, used mostly by 1031 exchangers who want a passive replacement property. A deferred sales trust is a way to sell on the installment method to a trust that invests the proceeds.

One keeps you in real estate and defers all of the gain. The other takes you out of real estate and spreads the gain over the years you are paid. Sellers often hear about both in the same week, usually from someone who sells one of them, so it helps to see them next to each other.

How a Delaware statutory trust works

A sponsor buys a building, often a net-leased retail, industrial, apartment or medical property, through a Delaware statutory trust, then sells beneficial interests to investors. If you buy an interest with exchange proceeds through your qualified intermediary, it counts as like-kind replacement property.

Rev. Rul. 2004-86 is the reason. The IRS held that a trust like this is a grantor trust, so each investor is treated as owning an undivided fractional interest in the real estate, and that an exchange into it qualifies under Section 1031. The ruling's trust works only because the trustee's hands are tied: it may not accept new capital after the offering, may not buy other property or reinvest sale proceeds, may not renegotiate the lease or the loan except in a tenant bankruptcy, may make only minor non-structural changes, must hold cash reserves in short-term government obligations or bank deposits, and must distribute available cash regularly.

Those limits are what make it passive. They are also why a sponsor cannot easily fix a problem property: if a tenant leaves or a loan comes due, trust documents commonly allow conversion to an LLC to get flexibility back.

Because the trust can carry nonrecourse debt, an interest can also help you replace the mortgage you paid off on the property you sold, which a full 1031 requires.

How a deferred sales trust works

Before closing, you agree to sell your asset to a trust for its installment note. The trust sells the asset to your buyer for cash, the trustee invests the cash, and the trust pays you interest and principal on an agreed schedule. You report the gain under Section 453 as principal arrives, using the same Form 6252 math as any installment sale.

Its strengths are breadth and flexibility. It works for a business, private stock or a home with gain above the Section 121 exclusion, none of which a 1031 can cover. The proceeds can go into a diversified portfolio rather than one building. And because your buyer pays cash, you carry no buyer credit.

Its tax footing is narrower than a Delaware statutory trust's. No revenue ruling, notice or listed-transaction designation names a deferred sales trust, for or against. The position rests on the trust being a real, independent buyer whose note is not a payment to you at closing (Section 453(f)(3)). If you control the trustee or can reach the cash, the IRS can treat you as having received the money (Treas. Reg. 1.451-2), and a note secured by cash counts as a payment (Temp. Reg. 15a.453-1(b)(3)(i)). In 2025 a Washington appeals court also upheld a finding that one deferred sales trust arrangement was an unregistered security (Mariani).

Worked example: one $2,000,000 sale, two trusts

Assumptions (illustrative, engine output): married couple filing jointly, $150,000 of other income, 2026 federal rules, Texas. Rental sold for $2,000,000; basis $800,000; gain $1,200,000, of which $400,000 is unrecaptured Section 1250 gain. No mortgage, no selling costs. A cash sale would owe $314,953 of federal tax on the gain in 2026.

The deferred sales trust column is the ordinary installment-sale result for that schedule; it holds only if the trust is respected as the buyer, and the payments depend on the portfolio covering them after fees. At 1% a year in total fees, a $2,000,000 portfolio pays $20,000 a year to the people running it. The Delaware statutory trust column depends on the property's rent and its eventual sale price, after sponsor fees.

Suspended losses and state tax along the way

Suspended passive losses. A 1031 into a Delaware statutory trust is not a fully taxable sale, so losses suspended on the building you sold stay suspended (Section 469(g)). They are not frozen, though: your share of the trust's net rent is passive income, and the losses absorb it year by year. Whatever is left is freed when the trust sells for cash and you take the cash, and is largely lost if you hold until death. A deferred sales trust is an installment sale, so the sold building's suspended losses are released in proportion to the gain you report each year (Section 469(g)(3)), provided the trust is not a related party.

State tax. A Delaware statutory trust property in another state can create a filing obligation there for your share of the rent. California follows Section 1031 but asks for an annual information return when California property is exchanged for property elsewhere, and taxes the deferred California gain when the replacement is sold. Deferred sales trust payments are generally taxed by your state of residence, and some states, California among them, can tax installment gain from in-state property after you move.

Costs and fees

Delaware statutory trust offerings layer selling commissions, sponsor acquisition fees, financing fees, annual asset management fees and a disposition fee or profit share at sale. Much of the load is taken up front, so the property has to perform for years to earn it back. The private placement memorandum lists each one.

Deferred sales trusts carry setup and legal fees, an annual trustee fee and investment management fees on the whole portfolio. They are not standardized.

For either, ask for every fee in writing, in dollars, and compare the net expected income with a direct installment sale, which costs an attorney and little else.

Control, liquidity and the exit

With a Delaware statutory trust you give up control on purpose: no management, no decisions, no tenant calls. You also give up timing. The sponsor decides when the property sells, often several years out. At that point you can take cash and pay the deferred tax, exchange again into another property, or in some programs roll into a REIT operating partnership. Selling your interest early is hard: there is no ready resale market.

With a deferred sales trust, the exit is the end of the note. Payments arrive on schedule, but asking for more, borrowing against the note or changing the terms can undo the deferral, which is why the documents limit you.

Heirs and estate planning

A Delaware statutory trust interest held at death gets a basis step-up to fair market value (Section 1014), so the gain deferred through every exchange can disappear for your heirs. An unpaid deferred sales trust note does not: it is income in respect of a decedent, and the heirs report the remaining gain as they are paid (Sections 691 and 1014(c)). For a seller who expects to hold until death, that difference can be larger than every fee on the page.

Which fits which seller

A Delaware statutory trust fits a real estate seller who wants to stay in real estate, wants no management, is an accredited investor, can leave the money in for years, and values the step-up at death.

A deferred sales trust fits a seller of a business, stock or real estate who is done with real estate, wants a managed portfolio, and accepts the fees and an untested tax position after a CPA has reviewed the documents.

Consider a direct installment sale if what attracts you to the deferred sales trust is spreading the tax: the same Section 453 result is available from your buyer's own note, secured by what you sold, on settled law. See deferred sales trust vs installment sale and the Big Sale Tax Analysis.

Frequently asked questions